Friday, May 02, 2008

SageTV HD Extender Gets Reviewed Again - And Misunderstood Again


PC World decided to take a stab at reviewing the SageTV HD100 Extender and did a decent job at some of the main points, but as often happens with HTPC components, the reviewer didn't really understand what he had.  He seemed to be under the impression that the device had to be close to his PC and that wireless is a key feature in an HTPC extender.  While wireless would be nice, it's extremely unlikely that HD streaming across a WiFi network would provide consistently good results in most homes.

An other con that was focused on was difficult setup. I think this stems from non SageTV users have more difficulty getting the SageTV software installed on their server PC. It also stems from a total misunderstanding of the device they are reviewing - the reviewer lumped it in the same category with the AppleTV, Netgear EVA800 and Dlink DSM520.

A quote by the PCWorld reviewer that made me scratch my head more than once (emphasis mine):

"I had to laugh at the included 1.5-meter ethernet cord; if only my TV were that close to my PC"

Lets just say it's difficult to get a good idea of the device being reviewed when the reviewer doesn't even understand what he's dealing with.

Check out the PCWorld Review or  the Crunchgear SageTV HD100 review for their take.

And if you missed it, check out my review of the SageTV HD100 Extender.  I wrote it from the perspective of a long-time HTPC user, but one who had used Beyond TV and Meedio before it as my primary HTPC software.

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Hauppauge HD-PVR Shipping Delayed to Mid-May

Hauppauge HD-PVR

Are you one of the many anxiously awaiting Hauppauge's new HD-PVR? If you go to the Hauppauge website it still tells us that the HD-PVR will begin shipping on May 1st, 2008 (see screen-shot taken today below.) But there is new information that says that isn't the case.

Hauppauge HD-PVR Website

Unfortunately, I have confirmed with Hauppauge that the first shipments will not happen on May 1st. Instead, the earliest, expected shipment dates are mid-May 2008. I'm a little disappointed in this, but not all that surprised. I've heard from representatives of SageTV and Snapstream (BeyondTV) and both of them seem to be as ready for the device as possible, but word is Hauppauge is still working on the drivers to get them just right. If this means the drivers will work better with the software then it is certainly the best decision to get thing right before putting it in the hands of the users, but I'm still a little disappointed.


If you've already pre-ordered, here's how to tell when your expected shipment date will be according to Hauppague:

  • For those with an online order # of 32700-33600 you're first in line - your HD-PVR should ship by Mid-May 2008
  • For those with an online order # of 33601-34600 you're second in line - your HD-PVR should ship by the end of May 2008

If you're order number is after 34600, it will likely be after May 2008.


At first glance, I thought this information might mean Hauppauge had sold approximately 1,900 pre-orders, but it was pointed out to me that Hauppauge of course sells other stuff (duh) so it's difficult to say how many HD-PVRs are in those number.

I was originally set to post a detailed "everything you need to know about the Hauppauge HD-PVR" post tomorrow, but given this news I'll probably wait until closer to the shipping date. If you have specific questions about the device you want me to cover, let me know in the comments. I also plan to review the device very near shipment date so stay tuned to Geek Tonic!

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

Blackberry Curve Arrives.... Broken

Well, for anyone following my quandary of which phone to get after a long (probably too long) time deciding, I went with the free Blackberry Curve.  It makes sense given the fact that I'll use thing primarily as a work organization tool (Outlook is what we use) and secondly as a phone and lastly as a web device.  The iPhone is cool for sure, but won't handle my business needs right now.  Add to that the cost factor and the Blackberry was (should have been) an easy choice.

Blackberry Curve

Well my Blackberry Curve arrived fully set up yesterday so I charged it fully and was ready to play with my new gadget.  Guess what?  After about 10 - 15 seconds of navigating, it rebooted itself.  I mean it totally crashed and started up again.  It continued to do this over and over until I pulled the battery to stop my frustration.  I tried lots of different things to get it to work to no avail.  Rather than search the internet for solutions, I decided not to hassle with it - especially since it is new and the IT group will just replace it with a new one that hopefully works.

This sort of thing has been a recurring theme for me this year....

Reviewing the Firefly HTPC Remote Control

When you purchase a Tivo or rent a Cable or Satellite DVR box the remote is part of the package -many times not even part of the decision.  But when you buy or build your own Home Theater PC (HTPC) choosing a remote control can mean the happiness or dissatisfaction with your powerful HTPC system.  The remote control is the unsung hero - many times a forgotten, but very important component of the HTPC setup.  Because of the great deal of versatility the HTPC brings the user, a HTPC remote control really needs to be a jack-of-all-trades remote.  A HTPC remote's job is very difficult since it controls TV, Movies, Music, Photos and more and ideally it should also control the television, receiver and any other AV equipment you use in your setup. 


Snapstream, the maker of Beyond TV has been selling one of the more popular HTPC remote controls, the Firefly remote control for several years now.


SnapStream provided Team Zatz Not Funny the remote control for review so I have my hands on Snapstream's Firefly PC Remote Control made just for the HTPC.  There are two versions of the Firefly, the original Firefly and the Firefly Mini.  Today, we'll focus on the original Firefly.  The Firefly is for sale at the Snapstream Store and retails for $49.95.  The Firefly remote is RF-based instead of most remotes that are infra-red.  This means it works without needing line-of-sight to work like infrared remotes do.  The advantage of RF is that it can work through walls, sofas, cabinets etc.  The disadvantage of RF is that most other devices such as TVs, DVD players etc are set up to work with IR remotes and don't work with the RF signals that the Firefly uses - but we'll get to that later in the review.

I tested this remote using my Home Theater PC that has SageTV, Beyond TV and Beyond Media programs installed on it and have also tested it with Media Portal, Power DVD and VLC to name a few.  My primary test software was with BeyondTV though since that is the software made by the same company that makes this remote.



You'll find the Firefly fits nicely in your hand.  It measures just under 8" long, 2" wide and 1.4" thick.  It looks fairly sleek and is silver in color.  In person it has a toy-like look to me, but not so much it takes away from the appearance.  The Firefly is pretty light - just under 5 ounces with the two AA batteries (included with the remote.)  The batteries fit into a spot on the underside of the remote control.


Dimensions (W x H x D):
2.07" x 7.94" x 1.40"
5.3cm x 20.2cm x 3.6cm

Weight (With Batteries):
4.7oz (132 grams)

Weight (Without Batteries):
3.9oz (108 grams)

48 total

433.92 Mhz

2 x AAA (included)


The Firefly remote is shaped to fit the hand comfortably.  It's shaped narrow in the middle and expands towards the front and back of the remote.  It's colored with metallic silver with gray and white rubber buttons that protrudes upward more than most remote control buttons do.





The firefly comes packaged with the following:

  • Firefly PC Remote
  • USB, RF receiver
  • CD (drivers and Beyond Media Basic)
  • Installation guide
  • User's guide
  • Two AAA batteries



The first thing I noticed about the Firefly is there is no IR emitter on the top or front of the remote since it's RF-based.  There is an LED at the top of the remote that flashes when its transmitting to the receiver.

The buttons are grey and shaped into squares that stick up from the remote more than most remotes buttons do.  The center button has the trademark Firefly logo and name on it which some will find nice, but I don't really care for all that much.  Many of the buttons are labeled above the buttons (not on the button) while others are labeled with black on white labels.  There is no backlighting so you'll need a light on in the room to operate until you get very familiar with the layout of the buttons.

The Firefly includes 48 buttons - many of which you will not find on a traditional, universal remote control.  Things that expose the Firefly as the HTPC-specific remote that it is include the Maximize/Minimize Button, the Close Button, Right-click and Left-click buttons for instance.

The keypad is organized in a familiar way that is fairly easy to get used to.  From the tope are the maximize and close buttons (HTPC specific) followed by the number keys, back enter, volume up and down on the left and channel up and down on the right.  In the middle is the firefly button which is large and sticks out from the other buttons.  This button's look isn't really for me, but it doesn't really take away from the remote and since it is called the firefly...


Next there is the info, option, menu and exit buttons all around the cursor control buttons in the center of the remote.  These easy-to use, 5-way menu cursor control buttons in the center of the remote have four directions and the ok button in the center.  Just below the menu and exit buttons are the record, play and stop buttons.  By the way, you'll notice from the photo that the menu and exit buttons can also function as the left and right mouse-click on your HTPC - something you won't find in your run-of-the-mill remote control.


Finally at the bottom of the remote is the rewind, pause, fast-forward, skip back, and skip forward buttons.  At the very bottom is a music, photos, dvd, tv, video, help, mouse and then the programable A, B, C and D buttons.



Overall, I was happy with the button layout.  The buttons I use the most are where I would expect them to be.  I also liked thought the "activity" buttons such as the music, photos, dvd etc are all at the bottom of the remote since they would be used less often. 



Since the Firefly is an RF remote, it requires a receiver that attaches to your HTPC through the USB port.  The Firefly has a black USB-attached receiver that is just over 2" wide and 3" deep.  The antenna that comes out of the back of the receiver is about 6" long.  The receiver has a red LED that tells you when its powered on.



  1. Insert the 2 included AA batteries into the bottom of the Firefly Remote Control
  2. Install the latest firmware (1.2.1 has been the latest version for quite a while) using the included CD or download from the Snapstream website.  Install using the Firefly.exe.
  3. When prompted, plug the USB RF receiver into a USB port on your HTPC. DSC03875

The instructions recommend you place the receiver in plain view, not covered by anything and not close to your HTPC, or AV equipment.  I tried placing the receiver in various places as much as the USB cord would allow.  My experience was that placing the receiver lower to the ground gave me the best reception. 

The Firefly Remote Control ships with a limited version of Snapstream's Beyond Media program which may be useful for some, but it is fairly limited in usefulness so I expect that if you don't already have a favorite HTPC software program you'll be looking for HTPC software with more functionality.  You can purchase the full version of Snapstream's full-version of Beyond Media (I used to use this as my HTPC front-end) but even that program has been basically left to die on the vine so to speak as Snapstream has failed to update the software in any way (except for adding ability for it to work with Vista) for several years now.  Instead, I recommend you use it with Beyond TV, SageTV, Media Portal, Media Center, GBPVR or any of the other excellent HTPC programs available.

While I don't recommend you use Beyond Media Basic (or Beyond Media for that matter) Beyond Media Basic is installed with the Firefly driver and is required even if you never plan to use Beyond Media Basic.  This is something that should definitely be changed with the installation.  There are alternatives to using the installation software with Beyond Media Basic which I'll cover later.


Once you've installed the Firefly drivers, you'll see a screen with setting that ask if you want to use Windows Media Center Edition or Beyond Media Basic as the primary media software.  Then you'll see a short five screen tutorial that explains most of the functions with a description of each of Firefly's buttons.  After the tutorial is complete, you can configure the receiver to recognize more than one Firefly remote, enable/disable the on-screen display (shows any time a remote button is pressed) and set the Firefly to run on PC startup.  Next you can set the Beyond Media Basic "interface settings" which I didn't use.

The final settings to be configured are the bottom activity buttons found at the bottom of the remote.  While the box the Firefly comes in says it supports over 80 devices with more to come (that's what was initially said by Snapstream), it still seems to support those 80 devices with few updates by Snapstream since.  While this is disappointing you'll find that there are some excellent alternatives that make the Firefly work with almost any device just as you would expect it to.  You then configure the media buttons, the "A, B, C & D" activity buttons and the "firefly" button.  Using the configuration software this process wasn't as easy as I had hoped since you can't easily assign programs to these buttons.  Read this post on the Snapstream Forums to learn about configuring these buttons using the Firefly Profiles,


As mentioned above the Firefly controls a wide variety of media apps out of the box, including Beyond TV and it can be customized to support additional programs as well.  Unfortunately, many newer versions of programs are not supported out-of-the-box.  For instance the latest version of PowerDVD (7 & 8) and Quicktime weren't supported out-of the box.  This meant I would have to do some searching and work to get the remote to control things the way I wanted which takes away from the easy of setup.  There is a solution which involves checking out the Snapstream Forums for the user-created Firefly profiles for various programs.  This was fairly easy for me, but I would expect the process to be easier for most HTPC consumers.

So what do you do if you don't find a profile that does what you need it to?  While it's not really mentioned much in the documentation, there are two tools that install with Firefly.  ProfileEditor.exe and AppIdentifier.exe are both used to create and edit profiles and work to get your firefly working the way you want it to.  This gave me the flexibility I needed, but it took quite a bit more work than I expected - even for a HTPC remote.


Using the default firefly driver and software, the remote works fairly well.  It can control those devices as listed in the installation, but go beyond that and it takes a bit more work.  If you plan to use it with Snapstream's Beyond Media or BeyondTV it works very well indeed.  Button presses provide quick response in these applications and work just as you'd expect them to.  There's even a mouse mode (hit the mouse button toggle) to control the mouse on the HTPC -something nice and not often found on remote controls.  With some extra work and time, I was able to configure the firefly remote control to work with non-Snapstream HTPC software such as SageTV, Media Portal and GBPVR.


My main problems with the Firefly Remote Control are the fact that it cannot control your TV, your AV receiver or any other IR-based device unless you install another third party software such as girder or eventghost.  It is possible, but it requires another device such as the USBUIRT and another piece of software.  To me this is the biggest bummer of an otherwise excellent remote control.  The one other thing I didn't like is the difficult process of finding and configuring profiles that enable the firefly to control other software programs not included in the initial install. 


If you like the sound of the RF-based Firefly Remote Control, but want more than the default configuration software the Snapstream provides, I recommend you check out the LM Remote KeyMap program.  This software replaces the Beyond Media Basic software that comes with the Firefly and is updated regularly to handle many additional PC programs.  It also handles other popular, PC remote controls as well.  LM Remote allows you to easily assign a wide range of functions to all of the Firefly Remote Control buttons using it's friendly graphical interface.  Launch and control many programs, keystrokes all within it's program.  It's really the configuration software that should have come with the Firefly and I consider it a must-have for any Firefly Remote Control owner.  The standard version of LM Remote is free, but the full version is donationware.

Girder is another excellent option that with the USBUIRT can add that missing functionality of controlling your other AV components including the TV.  Eventghost is another option like girder and it's even free.




  • Inexpensive
  • Capable of completely customizing with alternative software
  • Nice button layout with specialized HTPC function buttons
  • Mouse control
  • Excellent range - RF through cabinets and walls
  • Many user-based alternative solutions to the default driver/software


  • Cannot control IR-based devices such as TV or Receiver
  • Driver/Software that comes with remote hasn't been updated much - difficult and time intensive to setup
  • Sometimes finicky about RF receiver placement

Snapstream's Firefly Remote Control is a well thought out design that was made with HTPCs in mind.  If you're willing to put in a little extra time to get it configured just right, you'll have an excellent HTPC remote control.  Just know that without some extra hardware and software, you cannot control your TV or AV Receiver power and volume.  With those reservations I recommend the Firefly Remote Control for HTPC users.  There are many satisfied Firefly users that you will find using Beyond TV, SageTV, MCE, Vista Media Center, GBPVR, Media Portal, MythTV, Meedios and many other popular HTPC programs.  That alone proves the success of the Firefly.  Thanks to Dave Zatz and Rakesh Agrawal for giving me the chance to review the Firefly Remote Control.

You can purchase the Firefly Remote Control from Snapstream at this website for $49.95.


Snapstream also sells a mini version of the Firefly Remote Control aptly named the Firefly Mini.  I'll be reviewing the mini in the next few days for comparison.




Monday, April 28, 2008

CrunchGear Reviews the SageTV HD Extender

Crunchgear has a review of the SageTV HD100 Extender up this week.

  This review was done from the perspective of a person who doesn't already use SageTV as their HTPC software.  I'll agree that SageTV isn't the easiest HTPC program to set up, but the Crunchgear review knocked off marks on the extender by saying

"The problem is that it has to win people away from their current media center software or hope to entice newcomers to adopt SageTV as their media center software of choice."

I would counter that argument by saying anyone who doesn't already own an HTPC program should definitely consider SageTV for their HTPC software - especially if they want a silent but powerful extender that fits in nicely in the entertainment center.  And for those who already own a competing HTPC program the HD Extender is something SageTV has going for it that really can't be equaled even by Vista Media Center in my opinion.

Check out the Crunchgear SageTV HD100 review for their take.


And if you missed it, check out my review of the SageTV HD100 Extender.  I wrote it from the perspective of a long-time HTPC user, but one who had used Beyond TV and Meedio before it as my primary HTPC software.